Skip to content
Clear Reels Central offers in-depth film reviews, behind-th…

Our King, Our Priest, Our Feudal Lord – How AI Is Taking Us Back to the Medieval Era.

This past summer, I was caught in congested traffic on the sweltering streets of Marseille. At an intersection, my companion in the front seat advised a right turn toward a famous spot for bouillabaisse. However, the navigation app on my phone commanded us to go forward. Weary and in a stifling car, I heeded the algorithm's advice. Minutes later, we were stuck at a roadwork site.

A minor event, maybe. But one that encapsulates a defining question of our era, where digital tools touches almost every aspect of existence: whom do we trust to a greater degree – other people and our personal instincts, or the machine?

The Enlightenment's Promise and A Contemporary Backslide

The renowned German philosopher Immanuel Kant once defined the Enlightenment as "humanity's emergence from its self-inflicted nonage." This state, he wrote, "represents the incapacity to use one's own understanding without guidance from another." For centuries, that guiding "other" for human thought was often the priest, the monarch, or the feudal lord – figures purporting to channel divine will. To comprehend phenomena like changing seasons, people sought answers in religion. In shaping the fabric of society, from commerce to love, religious doctrine served as the main compass.

“Sapere aude!” or “Have courage to use your own understanding!”

Kant argued that humans had the capacity for reason. They simply lacked the confidence to use it. With upheavals in America and France, a new dawn emerged: logic would supplant blind faith, and the human mind, liberated from authority, would become the engine of progress and a better world.

Today, two and a half centuries later, one might wonder if we are slipping back into a form of intellectual immaturity. An app suggesting a direction is just one example. AI risks becoming our contemporary authority – a silent guide that steers our choices and behaviors. We are in danger of relinquishing the historically earned courage to think independently – and this time, not to deities or rulers, but to computer programs.

The Swift Adoption and Subtle Dangers of AI Dependence

ChatGPT debuted a mere three years ago, and already a global survey found that an vast number of people had used AI in the previous six months. Whether contemplating a breakup or selecting a vote, individuals are increasingly turning to machines for counsel. Data suggests a large majority of user queries concern personal life matters. Even more intriguing than our use of AI for advice is what happens when we allow it express for us. Composition is now among the top uses for generative AI, second only to everyday tasks. The late American author Joan Didion once remarked, “I write entirely to find out what I am thinking.” What occurs when we stop composing? Do we cease discovering?

Worryingly, emerging research hints the answer may be yes. A study from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology used electroencephalography to observe the cognitive activity of participants who had could use AI, traditional search engines, or nothing. Those who could rely on AI showed the lowest cognitive engagement and had difficulty quoting their own work. Maybe most troubling was that after a few months, individuals in the AI group became increasingly reliant, pasting large sections of text.

“Inertia and fear,” Kant wrote, “are the reasons why so many of men … stay in perpetual nonage.”

Certainly, AI's appeal stems from its efficiency. It is fast, reduces effort and – critically – offers a novel way to offload accountability. In his 1941 book, Escape from Freedom, the German psychoanalyst Erich Fromm argued that the rise of fascism could be partly explained by a human tendency to give up autonomy in for the sake of the reassuring certainty of subordination. AI offers a digital method of relinquishing the weight of having to decide for oneself.

The Black Box Problem: Trust Without Understanding

AI's primary draw is its capacity to accomplish things beyond our minds – sifting through oceans of data at unprecedented speed. Stuck in the car in Marseille, this was, ultimately, why I chose to trust the machine over my friend (a decision she interpreted as an affront). With access to real-time information, certainly the algorithm had superior insight – or so I thought.

The core issue is that AI is a black box. It produces knowledge, but without necessarily deepening human understanding. We do not truly know the process behind its conclusions – even its programmers admit this. Nor can we check its logic against transparent standards. So when we follow AI's recommendation, we are not being guided by reason. We are returning to the domain of belief. In dubio pro machina: when in doubt, trust the machine – that may become our future guiding principle.

Harnessing Without Eroding: The Essential Challenge

AI can be a formidable ally for humanity in rational inquiry. It can aid in inventing drugs, free us from tedious tasks, or handle taxes – duties that are repetitive and are unfulfilling. This is beneficial. But Kant and his peers did not advocate for enlightenment just so humans could optimize chores or have more leisure. Critical thinking was not merely about productivity – it was a discipline of freedom and human self-determination.

Human thought is often chaotic and fallible, but it forces us to debate, to doubt, to challenge concepts – and to acknowledge the boundaries of our own understanding. It fosters confidence, both personally and collectively. For Kant, the use of reason was never solely about information; it was about empowering people to become authors of their own destinies, and to resist control. It was about creating a moral community based on the shared principle of reason and debate, rather than unquestioning acceptance.

With all the advantages AI brings, the key question is this: how can we leverage its potential of advanced capability without undermining human rationality, the bedrock of the Enlightenment and of liberal democracy itself? That is likely one of the defining questions of our time. It is a question we must strive not to delegate to the algorithm.

The writer

Bethany Thompson

A film critic and industry analyst with over a decade of experience covering Hollywood and independent cinema.

Clear Reels Central

Type to search articles.